Casper vs Tempur-Pedic (The Best Comparison Guide of 2022): Which is the Perfect Mattress for You?
Tempur-Pedic’s LuxeAdapt
Which one is better? The Tempur-Pedic LuxeAdapt or the Casper Original? All things considered, we recommend the Tempur-Pedic LuxedAdapt Mattress because of its premium construction, pressure relief and motion isolation. However, if you’re looking for value for your hard-earned money, the Original Casper isn’t a bad pick either. They key is to ask yourself to choose a mattress that suits your specific needs. See more details in our complete comparison guide below.
Overview
You have decided to get a new mattress finally. But you’re confronted with endless options, with brands claiming they are “the best” – leaving you stressed in making the actual, smart decision.
What if we narrow it down for you to two brands? Allow us to help you as we share our side-to-side comparison of two of the biggest names in the mattress world – Casper and Tempur-Pedic.
We base our comparison on these factors:
- Construction and Design
- Similarities & Differences
- Firmness Feel
- Sleep Performance
- Prices and Sizes
To help you make a well-informed decision – our team has spent substantial time in reviewing these two brands to provide you with credible and significant information.
For now, read our full review of Tempur-Pedic’s LuxeAdapt and the Original Casper to find out which of them suits you best.
Who Are They?
First off, a quick background check on the two companies along with what type of mattresses they offer to their existing and potential customers.
Casper
Although the brand is only six years old, it is already one of the more popular mattresses when online shopping is concerned. Its mattresses’ superb, all-around quality makes it ideal for just about anyone.
Tempur-Pedic
The brand came about during the early 90s, 1992 to be exact, and has since then provided quality mattresses for customers. Their mattresses are best known for their luxury feel and excellent pressure relief capabilities.
What About Their Construction and Design?
Now that you know a little bit about the two competing brands, let’s now move to the elements that make up the two mattresses. Although both feature a four-layer design, they are both far different when it comes to the materials.
Tempur-Pedic
- First Layer – This is the comfort layer, and it is made out of Tempur-Pedic’s own Tempu-ES foam. The special foam has a slow response to pressure and that allows your body to sink into the mattress for fantastic pressure relief. With its plush feel, it can help make sleepers feel like they are floating all night long.
- Second Layer – Right after the comfort layer is the contour layer, and it is composed of another Tempur-Pedic signature memory foam material called the Tempur-APR+. It has a tighter cell construction than that of the foam above it, and it allows the sleeper to plunge further into the mattress for added pressure relief.
- Third Layer – Now we have the transitional layer. Tempur-Pedic’s transitional layer is made of a soft polyfoam that eases off the pressure when hitting the support layer below it.
- Fourth Layer – Lastly, we have the support layer---made of a highly dense polyfoam. It’s meant to provide much needed support for the people lying down and gives the bed its shape.
- Cover – With Tempur-Pedic’s cover, we have a mix of polyester and a Phase Change Material. Overall, it is highly breathable and elastic. Plus, the Phase Change Material is woven to add a cooling effect so that a person can experience a cooler surface to help them during warm nights.
Casper
- First Layer – Casper’s comfort layer is composed of an open cell foam with similar capabilities of a natural latex. The latex-like foam provides natural cooling, superb bounce, and highly responsive qualities to make it easier to toss and turn. The open cell design promotes airflow to help regulate body temperature.
- Second Layer – Now let’s move on to what is beneath the comfort layer, which is the contour section. It is made out of a memory foam that is slow to respond when pressure is applied and enables users to sink into the mattress allowing pressure relief.
- Third Layer – This is the transition layer, which is where Casper stands out the most. This layer offers sleepers a Zoned Support type of polyfoam. That means, the top portion of the layer is soft to offer pressure relief for the shoulders, and the center of the section is much firmer, providing support for the hips.
- Fourth Layer – Of course, we have the support layer or the base of the mattress. It is made of a high density polyfoam that not only gives the mattress its shape, but also provides much needed support from the three foam layers above.
- Cover – The cover is made of a super soft polyester material. Plus, it is removable for easier cleaning.
Similarities & Differences
Now, let’s discuss some qualities that make these mattresses similar and qualities that can help you pick the best one for your home. Knowing the similarities and differences of two products can help you understand each brand better, and, ultimately, help your decision a lot easier.
Similarities
- Both brands offer plenty of mattress models to customers so that they can choose the perfect bed for themselves.
- Both are constructed with an all-foam design. However, both use different types of foam material that gives a unique feel to the two beds.
- Both provide excellent pressure relief capabilities that are highly common for all foam mattresses. This is fantastic for critical areas around the body, such as the hips, shoulders, neck, and back.
Differences
- Tempur-Pedic offers plenty of comfort level options for customers to choose from, while Casper only offers a medium-firm feel with regards to its beds.
- The prices are probably the biggest difference. The price tags of Tempur-Pedic beds are over a thousand dollars ($1,000), yes, you read that right, more compared to what Casper offers. We know that beds and other home furniture are an investment. That is why it all depends on your situation. If you can afford a $3,000 mattress, go for it; if not, that is okay, too. Choose the mattress that you want or need.
- As you already know, their transitional layers are unique from each other. The Tempur-Pedic provides a soft polyfoam while Casper provides a polyfoam with zoned support in place for both pressure relief and support.
What About Their Firmness Feel?
Now that you know about their similarities, differences, and construction, let’s discuss how these two mattresses feel on a firmness scale. Note that on the firmness scale, 1 means it’s super soft without providing any support and 10 means that the mattress is extremely firm while offering no comfort at all.
Tempur-Pedic
On the firmness scale, Tempur-Pedic’s LuxeAdapt Mattress lands on the middle of the scale. Scoring a 5 on the firmness scale, that means that there is no question that this mattress is tremendously soft. Comparing it to the industry standard of 6.5, that really tells you just how soft the bed is.
When you first lay down on the bed, you first notice the coolness of the cover, thanks to the phase change material. Then, as you slowly sink into the mattress, you’ll feel the superb and satisfying pressure relief that Tempur-Pedic is best known for.
Casper
The bed’s score on the firmness scale is a solid 7. Although slightly higher and firmer than the 6.5 standard, it still provides an excellent balance of comfort and support. With the zoned support polyfoam, even though you will sink into the mattress, you won’t sink in too much. Therefore, it will make moving around easier.
Casper’s mattress makes you sleep “on top” of it rather than “in” it that is common for memory foam mattresses. Though it is a firmer mattress for an all foam construction, it still provides quite satisfying pressure relief to major areas.
Overall, there are a couple of factors that can affect the feel and comfort level of both mattresses. These are: size, weight, and sleep position preference. For example: a soft mattress may be great for people with average and below average weights and for back and side sleepers. However, it won’t be too fantastic for people with above average weight and back sleepers. So, the firmness level entirely depends on those factors.
What About Sleep Performance?
When it comes to sleeping on a bed, it is not just about sleep. There are elements in a mattress that can affect your sleep entirely, such as Motion Transfer, Temperature Regulating Capabilities, Edge Support, Noise, and Pressure Relief. We’ll cover all except Pressure Relief as you already know that the two beds are excellent in that area.
Motion Transfer
This area is highly essential for couples. Any movement produced during the night can disturb someone’s sleep, especially when he or she is a light sleeper. That is why when shopping for a bed, they would need a mattress that offers wonderful Motion Transfer.
- Tempur-Pedic – Known for its accurate contouring, Tempur-Pedic’s mattress does a fantastic job of responding wherever pressure is applied. That means it only responds to areas with pressure, which also means that whoever you are sharing your bed with won’t feel any movement from your end.
- Casper – Although a firmer mattress compared to Tempur-Pedic, Casper still provides an exceptional job of isolating motion that is adequate for most people already.
Temperature Regulating Capabilities
During summer, it becomes warm even during the nights, which leads to a little less than comfortable sleep. However, even if it is not summer, some people still sleep hot, which can also get uncomfortable on its own. That is why choosing a bed that not only provides comfort and support, but also provides temperature neutrality is key.
- Tempur-Pedic – In general, there have been a few issues of Tempur-Pedic mattresses overheating, which is common for all memory foam beds as they store heat longer. For people who weigh above average would cause them to sink deeper into the mattress, and because of that, heat cannot properly escape, and ventilation cannot be fully achieved. However, it does bring a bit of coolness because of its Phase Change material-made cover.
- Casper – On the other hand, due to the fact that Casper beds have more firmness and bounce, it provides proper airflow to help bring down the heat. Also, the open cell design of the comfort layer also allows air to pass through allowing for even more ventilation.
Edge Support
Again, this section is also critical for shoppers who are sharing the bed with someone. A bed with fantastic edge support means you will less likely feel as though you’re falling from the mattress and does a fantastic job of supporting your weight when you sit down on the side of the bed.
- Tempur-Pedic – Because it is an all foam mattress, Tempur-Pedic’s LuxeAdapt does not do much for edge support. However, the brand’s Flex hybrid line of mattresses do a superb job in this regard.
- Casper – Unfortunately, all mattress lines from Casper do not perform well when talking about edge support.
Overall, if you are prioritizing edge support, we highly recommend looking at innerspring mattresses as they do well in that section over memory foam mattresses.
What Are Their Prices And Sizes?
Now that you know most of the key details regarding the two beds, it’s now time to jump into what’s probably the most important of all – their price tags. One thing is for certain, Tempur-Pedic is much more expensive compared to Casper. See more details below.
| Sizes | Price (Casper) | Price (Tempur-Pedic) |
|---|---|---|
|
Twin |
$695 |
$2,299 |
|
Twin XL |
$695 |
$3,199 |
|
Full |
$995 |
$3,649 |
|
Queen |
$1,095 |
$3,699 |
|
King |
$1,295 |
$4,399 |
|
California King |
$1,295 |
$4,399 |
Frequently Asked Questions
That entirely depends on what you are looking for in a mattress. If you are looking for a cheaper, firmer, and cooler bed, then we highly recommend Casper over Tempur-Pedic. See our detailed comparison of the two in our complete guide above.
There are plenty of brands that can compare to Tempur-Pedic. Some of them have cheaper mattresses while some offer prices that compete with Tempur-Pedic. Some of them are: Amerisleep, Puffy, Brooklyn Aurora, Nectar, and much more.
Overall, that entirely depends on you, if you like the feel, what they provide, and can afford their prices, we would say that it is definitely worth it. Mattresses are an investment, so think of it as an investment for yourself, for getting the sleep you deserve.
Conclusion
Before anything else, when shopping for a certain product, you need to know what you want and what you need. However, thanks to advertising, that is easier said than done, which is why we are here. We hope that by showing you detailed side-by-side comparisons between products, even though it’s just two of them, can help your shopping be a little less stressful.
With the Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses, it will come down to just that. So, we ask, “What are you looking for in a bed?”. If you can answer that, you will know what to pick. If you’re prioritizing your money, firm support, and breathability, we recommend Casper. But, if you’re looking for a posh, super soft, excellent motion isolation, and pressure relief, we recommend Tempur-Pedic.
Do you have any questions, clarifications, or reactions? Contact us now and we will listen and answer all of them for you.
