Mattress-In-A-Box Brands Compared: Casper vs. Puffy (Updated for 2022)
Casper vs. Puffy
Cooling and comforting, both the Puffy and the Casper have similar features. Also, both can be conveniently ordered online and delivered to you in a box. What more can you ask for in a mattress? However, which one is the clear winner? Find out by reading our full comparison of these two bed in a box brands.
Have you heard about the Puffy mattress? The company was founded a half-decade ago in 2016, and its name creates images of fluffy clouds, fat puppies and all things soft and well, puffy. Puffy’s homepage compares lying down on its comfortable mattress to sleeping on a cloud. It’s quickly become a leader in the bed in a box sector with products that include models like Puffy Lux mattress.
We’ll be making a comparison of the Puffy Royal mattress with the Original Casper mattress. These three-layer best mattresses have many similarities, including top layers with memory foam. Casper has been a pioneer of the market for those searching for a mattress online. We’ll address the similarities and differences of these two mattresses and how ideal they are for different types of sleepers.
The Puffy Mattress
This layer is designed to adjust to the sleeper and offers support as the back shifts during the night.
The middle layer includes 2 inches of transitional polyfoam.
FIRM CORE SUPPORT
This layer is designed specifically to keep the spine lined up while eliminating the sleeper’s pressure points.
The following payment options are available for Puffy Royal:
As low as $71/month
As low as $70.83/month
PLACE ON ANY SURFACE
The Puffy mattress in a box has been designed to position on any frame or surface. This includes various options such as:
Puffy has been ranked Number 1 in several Best Mattress categories for all sleeping positions.
The mattress’s allergy-friendly cover has been designed to help keep off various allergens, including dust mites, and protect the Puffy mattress (such as the king size mattress). This can help to prevent skin irritation, which is more likely among sleepers with sensitive skin and similar conditions.
BREATHABLE AND COOLING
The Cooling Gel Cloud layer of Puffy’s mattress is very breathable and designed for optimal temperature control. It’s cool to the touch and absorbs no heat. Thus, you can sleep uninterrupted as you cycle through the sleep stages, which can improve your overall sleep quality.
ENHANCED SPINAL ALIGNMENT
Puffy’s Cooling Cloud and Firm Core Support form has been designed to adjust to the human body. It provides support while the back shifts around during the nighttime.
TOTAL PRESSURE RELIEF
The Firm Core Support Layer is designed specifically to keep the sleeper’s spine aligned while ending pressure points.
STAIN RESISTANT COVER
The Puffy mattress includes the brand new Stain Resistant Cover. You can wipe up spills fast and easily while the cover stays clean and white. Puffy’s Zip-N-/Wash cover provides seasonal deep cleaning for removing stuff like dirt and bacteria that build up from regular mattress use.
DONATIONS TO CHILDREN IN NEED
Puffy donates to kids who need a bed because it believes every child should have a bed. This feature is beneficial for people who want to improve their communities through purchase decisions.
Studies show that only about half of school-aged children in the United States get 9 hours of sleep during weekdays. There are various causes of this health issue although it’s sometimes related to children lacking a comfortable mattress.
101-NIGHT SLEEP TRIAL
You can try sleeping on Puffy’s mattress for a complete 101 night sleep trial. If you’re not fully satisfied, you can return the mattress for free and get a full refund.
This is a critical feature since many sleep experts recommend that people test mattresses for at least two months before deciding to keep them. Another option is a test mattress, although this is less practical when purchasing mattresses from online retailers rather than brick & mortar stores.
The mattress is under warranty for the total time you own it. While some companies offer a multi-year warranty, a lifetime warranty provides better coverage since mattresses tend to last for an average of one decade.
MADE IN USA
Every part of the Puffy mattress is made in the USA. That includes its design, assembly, and sewing. When purchasing Puffy mattresses, you’re supporting local workers.
It’s also a more eco-friendly option since purchasing local mattresses produces a smaller carbon footprint. For example, international shipping costs can be quite high for large items like mattresses.
SHIPS FREE TO YOUR DOOR WITH FEDEX
FedEx ships the mattress to your doorstep for free within 1 to 3 business days. If you’re not fully satisfied, Puffy will pick up the mattress and provide a full refund. This can save consumers a significant amount of money due to the heavy weights of mattresses.
Feel & Firmness
The Casper Mattress
One layer of Airscape perforated breathable foam boosts airflow and air circulation to prevent hot sleeping due to factors like hot air temperatures. High-quality foam conforms to the body to reduce pressure.
The Zoned Support offers memory foam that contains three ergonomic zones for aligning the spine and offering extra relief:
The durable base is designed to prevent sagging and sinking while supporting the sleeper’s entire body.
Casper’s CertiPUR-US program certifies all its foams. They’re produced without any ozone-depleting chemicals, and the Consumer Product Safety Commission Low Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) Program regulates indoor air quality emissions.
38″ W x 75″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 53 lbs
Foam: 46 lbs
38″ W x 80″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 57 lbs
Foam: 50 lbs
53″ W x 75″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 76 lbs
Foam: 67 lbs
60″ W x 80″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 91 lbs
Foam: 79 lbs
76″ W x 80″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 112 lbs
Foam: 101 lbs
72″ W x 84″ L x 11″ H
Hybrid: 114 lbs
Foam: 100 lbs
3 ZONES OF SUPPORT
This feature provides all-night comfort by providing different kinds of support through the mattresses’ three layers.
PERFORATED BREATHABLE FOAM
This helps to keep sleepers cool at night and is especially ideal for “hot sleepers.” While the body’s internal temperature drops while sleeping, the skin temperature increases. Thus, it’s important for a mattress to have good airflow.
AVAILABLE IN ALL-FOAM OR HYBRID
This offers more options. Hybrid mattresses combine memory foam and latex to provide the best of both materials. Both types of mattresses have pros and cons. For example, memory foam provides a high amount of support, while hybrid mattresses offer more bounce due to the springs. Hybrid mattresses also tend to have more durability than memory foam mattresses.
COVER MADE WITH UP TO 57 RECYCLED BOTTLES
This makes the mattress an eco-friendly option. It maintains the “3Rs.”
This offers convenience and cost-effectiveness since you won’t have to spend extra money on shipping costs.
100-NIGHT RISK-FREE TRIAL
The company promises you the best sleep of your life, or you can get a full refund. Sleep experts generally recommend that people try a mattress for at least one or two months before determining to keep it.
10-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY
This differs from Puffy’s lifetime warranty. It’s also important to learn about what the warranty does and doesn’t cover in case you have any issues.
DESIGNED BY CASPER LABS
Casper Laps launched in 2018, so the company’s mattresses have been on the market for a few years.
FREE/EASY PICKUP RETURNS
This prevents customers from needing to spend money on return shipping. It increases the chance dissatisfied consumers will consider returning a mattress.
Feel & Firmness
Casper has a medium-firm feel of 6.5 on the firmness scale. Casper Labs provides a bouncy and responsive foam feel. During bounce tests, a ball bounces up quite high. As a result, it should be easy to move on the Original Casper mattress without feeling like you’re stuck.
SLEEPING HOT OR COLD
Both the Puffy and Casper mattresses are all-foam beds that have cooling components, so it’s a tie. The Original Casper mattress has breathable AirScape foam to boost airflow around the mattress. Meanwhile, Puffy Royal has gel infusion to help prevent overheating.
This is a key feature when you have a sleeping partner since high motion transfer makes it more likely you’ll wake up when your partner moves.
The memory foam layer is effective for preventing motion throughout the bed and absorbing motion. Since Casper has more bounce, it performed less well with motion transfer.
Casper wins in this area. The firm base layer and Zoned Support system boost the mattress’s durability and create a much sturdier feel when either sitting or standing close to the edge.
Both the Puffy Royal and Original Casper mattresses are all-foam beds that are likely to last for around seven years. However, they might last longer if the mattresses are maintained well.
The funky smell results from fire retardants that are added to mattresses. It’s a tie between the two mattresses. Both seem to off-gas around the same amount.
The smells should become much weaker within a few days. This helps to prevent not getting 40 winks if you’re sensitive to strong smells.
The Puffy and Casper are basically even in this area. Neither of the mattresses produced much noise. Innerspring mattresses tend to be much louder than memory foam mattresses. This issue can be a major one in cases like being a light sleeper.
The Casper mattress includes a 10-year warranty as well as a 100-night sleep trial. Meanwhile, the Puffy mattress includes a lifetime warranty as well as a 101-night sleep trial. Puffy’s one-day longer sleep trial isn’t a major plus, although the lifetime warranty is more generous than Casper’s 10-year warranty.
Which mattress is better, Casper or Puffy?
Neither of these mattresses is significantly better than the other one. That said, they could provide better fits for various kinds of sleepers.
The Casper mattress is a good option for back sleepers who require a lot of lumbar support, combo sleepers, and sleepers who prefer foam mattresses with a lot of bounce.
The Puffy mattress (such as a full size mattress) is a good option for side sleepers of a light or medium weight, back sleepers that need less lumbar support, and people who like a balanced foam feel with a top layer that has a little memory foam.
In many ways, the Puffy Royal and Original Casper mattresses seem to be very similar at first. This is due to their three layers and memory foam construction. The Casper’s Zoned Support system makes it feel ideal for side-sleepers. However, the Puffy mattress seems to be more generally ideal for people who use any sleeping position.
There are some small differences between the two mattresses. For example, the Puffy mattress has foam at the top, which creates a slow-moving experience. Meanwhile, Casper has a slightly bouncier feel. Meanwhile, the prices of both mattresses are quite similar.
The Puffy mattress is ideal for light/medium-weight side-sleepers, and consumers who prefer a classic memory foam experience. The Casper is ideal for back sleepers who need more support. The bottom line is since this is a more niche group, we recommend Puffy as the better overall choice.